Celebs : Why Walmart got go-ahead

Walmart's acquisition of a majority stake in Massmart raised no competition concerns, but did raise some public interest issues, the Competition Tribunal said on Wednesday.


"It does raise certain public interest concerns, but these concerns are adequately remedied by the imposition of the conditions submitted as undertakings by the merging parties...," the tribunal said in a statement on its reasons for approving the deal.
The tribunal conditionally approved the deal on 31 May but only gave its reasons for this on Wednesday.
"Walmart does not compete with Massmart in South Africa and its only presence in the country is a small procurement arm that sources local products for its stores globally.
"In light of the above, we find that the transaction would not substantially prevent or lessen competition in any of the markets that Massmart presently operates in."
However, the Competition Act says a merger may still be prohibited or subject to conditions, on the grounds of public interest.
"... unless the merger is the cause of the public interest concerns, we have no remit to do anything about them. Our job in merger control is not to make the world a better place, only to prevent it becoming worse as a result of a specific transaction," the tribunal said.
In this case, the merging parties offered to undertake various steps to protect the public interest.
Unions were concerned that the merger would lead to job losses and that this had already started happening with some retrenchments last year.
"There is no evidence from the internal documents of the merging parties that retrenchments at Massmart are contemplated as a consequence of the merger," the tribunal found.
"On the contrary, there is evidence that suggests, given the expansionist ambitions of Massmart, the group expects employment to grow between 2011 and 2013."
The parties, however, gave an undertaking not to retrench staff for two years post-merger.
It was also agreed that the status of the SA Commercial Catering and Allied Workers' Union as the largest representative union within the merger entity would not be challenged for a period of three years.
The tribunal said, although muddled, it appeared the unions were demanding centralised bargaining and a closed shop.
However, it found that Massmart's approach to these two issues was a policy pre-merger and not influenced by a possible merger with Walmart.
The tribunal was wary of imposing labour conditions that should "be thrashed out at the bargaining table".
"Protecting existing rights is legitimate, creating new rights is beyond our competence."
Thus it found "the creation of additional rights not presently enjoyed by unions is neither merger specific nor appropriately part of our limited public interest mandate in respect of effects on employment".
Another issue raised during competition proceedings was that Walmart's substantial bargaining power, and access to cheap imports, could harm local procurement.
The tribunal said it was likely that the merged entity would change its procurement patterns, but it was not clear by how much.
"The problem is that the concern raised in relation to local procurement/imports is also associated with important benefits for consumers.
"A possible loss of jobs in manufacturing of an uncertain extent must be weighed up against a consumer interest in lower prices and job creation at Massmart."
The SA Clothing and Textile Workers' Union proposed that post merger Massmart's local procurement level should be kept at the same level as it was pre-merger for a certain amount of time.
But the tribunal said this would be too complex to implement.
"Further the conditions will contradict the major objective of competition regulation -- to secure lower prices -- the procurement conditions would likely affect the merged entity's ability to provide customers with the lowest possible prices."
Instead, the tribunal found the merging parties remedy of spending R100-million over three years on a local supplier programme, was more acceptable.
"Instead of insulating local industry from international competition for a period, it seeks to make local industry more competitive to meet international competition."
The merging parties made various undertakings about local procurement and labour conditions during the hearings, which they eventually agreed should be made conditions for the approval of the deal.
For this reason, the undertakings would be enforceable.
"Non-adherence can lead to serious consequences for the merger, which is an illustration of the commitment to them and an indication that it is not in consequence a public relations gesture."
Source BUSINESS.AFRICA

Rating: 0.00 (0 votes) - Rate this News -

Tags: and   Walmart   DionWired   Massmart   Makro   Game  


Other articles
2018/11/18 16:36:20 - purchase viagra nhsnzjpholdsb
2018/11/16 8:28:18 - generic cialis online bzbxbsstophiepsxl
2018/11/15 8:40:59 - cialis 10mg bbrbfjthoxyhespew
2018/11/13 14:36:12 - cialis daily ndrfzjjudgeuf
2018/11/12 6:34:02 - viagra alternatives nznvdMoispBtjexisyp
2018/11/8 16:48:47 - viagra information nanfdMoispBtjexisye
2018/11/2 13:42:23 - dolhsfjthoxyhesaxp
2018/10/28 4:45:30 - quick loans for bad credit jzhbsvdMoispBtjexisyv
2015/1/21 13:51:40 - All About That Bass: Research Shows That Curvier Women Produce More Intelligent Kids
2014/7/17 12:09:35 - Typhoon Kills 38 In The Philippines
2014/7/9 11:54:07 - What Did Jay Z Do? Woman Who Abandoned Baby In A Subway, Arrested And Shouts F*ck Shawn Corey Carter
2014/7/9 8:34:21 - Man Chokes And Die During Eating Contest
2014/7/7 14:08:19 - Neymar Causes Panic In His Camp
2014/7/7 13:12:37 - 60 Girls Escape Boko Haram Captors
2014/7/4 8:30:00 - 56 Year Old Woman Chases A 25 Year Old Man With A Knife After He Refused To Have Sex With Her.



Bookmark this article at these sites

                   

 
The comments are owned by the poster. We aren't responsible for their content.
2010 Abuse ANC and Anni Apple avatar Bafana Barack Britain Cape China crime Cup Dewani Eskom facebook FIFA Gaga Google Haiti HIV Internet iPad Jackson Jub Malema Manchester Mandela MaNtuli matric Michael Nelson New Obama of Oprah Prince Shrien SWC The tickets Tiger Transnet twitter United Winfrey Woods World Zuma
Powered by Sevafrica
None All Errors (1) Deprecated (0) Queries (37) Blocks (10) Extra (2) Timers(6)
Errors
Warning: XoopsEditorHandler::getList() should not be called statically. in file /class/xoopseditor/xoopseditor.php line 171
Deprecated
Queries
0.000566 - SET NAMES 'utf8'
0.000257 - SET SQL_BIG_SELECTS = 1
0.000268 - SELECT * FROM config WHERE (conf_modid = '0' AND conf_catid = '1') ORDER BY conf_order ASC
0.000659 - SELECT sess_data, sess_ip FROM session WHERE sess_id = 'k1ed84obc47klibobflagnss13'
0.000214 - SELECT * FROM modules WHERE dirname = 'news'
0.000189 - SELECT COUNT(*) FROM group_permission WHERE (gperm_modid = '1' AND (gperm_groupid = '3') AND gperm_name = 'module_read' AND gperm_itemid = '32')
0.000259 - SELECT * FROM config WHERE (conf_modid = '32') ORDER BY conf_order ASC
0.000295 - SELECT * FROM modules WHERE dirname = 'protector'
0.000860 - DELETE FROM protector_access WHERE expire < UNIX_TIMESTAMP()
0.000663 - SELECT COUNT(*) FROM protector_access WHERE ip='54.163.20.57' AND request_uri='/modules/news/article.php?storyid=1955'
0.000616 - SELECT COUNT(*) FROM protector_access WHERE ip='54.163.20.57'
0.000395 - INSERT INTO protector_access SET ip='54.163.20.57',request_uri='/modules/news/article.php?storyid=1955',expire=UNIX_TIMESTAMP()+'60'
0.001354 - SELECT s.*, t.* FROM stories s, topics t WHERE (storyid=1955) AND (s.topicid=t.topic_id)
0.000258 - SELECT COUNT(*) FROM group_permission WHERE (gperm_modid = '32' AND (gperm_groupid = '3') AND gperm_name = 'news_view' AND gperm_itemid = '4')
0.001165 - UPDATE stories SET counter = counter+1 WHERE storyid = 1955
0.000925 - SELECT COUNT(*) FROM banner
0.000752 - SELECT * FROM banner LIMIT 2, 1
0.000929 - UPDATE banner SET impmade = impmade+1 WHERE bid = 3
0.000389 - SELECT * FROM config WHERE (conf_modid = '0' AND conf_catid = '3') ORDER BY conf_order ASC
0.000421 - SELECT DISTINCT gperm_itemid FROM group_permission WHERE gperm_name = 'block_read' AND gperm_modid = 1 AND gperm_groupid IN (3)
0.000723 - SELECT b.* FROM newblocks b, block_module_link m WHERE m.block_id=b.bid AND b.isactive=1 AND b.visible=1 AND m.module_id IN (0,32) AND b.bid IN (415,414,413,396,395,394,380,379,378,377,376,375,374,373,372,371,370,369,368,367,366,365,364,360,362,361,480,481,363,356,477,355,354,353,357,358,359,352,351,350,349,348,347,346,344,343,345,339,340,341,342,338,337,463,335,334,333,332,330,329,328,327,326,331,325,324,323,320,319,318,321,322,317,316,313,312,311,314,315,306,305,304,307,308,309,310,202,201,200,199,198,197,195,194,193,192,191,190,189,188,187,186,185,181,182,183,184,168,154,153,157,169,171,172,173,178,158,170,167,155,156,166,161,160,159,196,134,133,132,131,130,129,128,127,126,125,124,123,122,121,120,119,118,117,116,109,110,111,476,482,478,479,485,483,77,52,51,53,54,15,14,13,12,11,10,9,8,7,6,5,4,3,2,1,411,410,409,408,407,406,405,403,402,563,404,401,399,398,393,391,390,389,388,387,386,385,384,412,383,382,381,294,293,292,291,290,289,288,210,207,206,205,204,203,179,135,112,208,209,562,115,136,180,68,67,39,303,17,16,416,417,418,421,422,423,426,427,428,429,434,435,436,437,438,439,440,441,442,443,444,518,446,447,448,449,450,451,454,455,456,457,458,459,460,461,462,464,465,466,467,468,469,470,471,472,473,474,475,513,487,488,489,490,491,492,493,494,512,511,496,497,498,499,500,501,502,503,504,505,506,507,508,515,510,516,520,521,522,523,524,525,526,527,528,529,530,531,532,533,534,535,536,537,550,539,540,541,542,543,544,545,546,548,549,551,552,553,554,555,556,557,558,559,560,561,564) ORDER BY b.weight, m.block_id
0.000356 - SELECT * FROM modules WHERE dirname = 'tag'
0.000383 - SELECT * FROM config WHERE (conf_modid = '63') ORDER BY conf_order ASC
0.000621 - SELECT DISTINCT(o.tag_id), o.tag_term, o.tag_status, SUM(l.tag_count) AS count, l.tag_modid FROM tag_tag AS o LEFT JOIN tag_stats AS l ON l.tag_id = o.tag_id WHERE (o.tag_status = '0') GROUP BY o.tag_id ORDER BY count DESC LIMIT 0, 50
0.000597 - SELECT * FROM smiles
0.000927 - SELECT * FROM stories_files WHERE storyid=1955
0.001254 - SELECT s.*, t.* FROM stories s, topics t WHERE (s.published > 0 AND s.published <= 1542597593) AND (s.expired = 0 OR s.expired > 1542597593) AND (s.topicid=t.topic_id) AND s.ihome=0 ORDER BY s.published DESC LIMIT 0, 15
0.001018 - SELECT storyid, title FROM stories WHERE (published > 0 AND published <= 1542597593) AND (expired = 0 OR expired > 1542597593) AND storyid > 1955 ORDER BY storyid ASC LIMIT 0, 1
0.000580 - SELECT storyid, title FROM stories WHERE (published > 0 AND published <= 1542597593) AND (expired = 0 OR expired > 1542597593) AND storyid < 1955 ORDER BY storyid DESC LIMIT 0, 1
0.000238 - SELECT * FROM topics ORDER BY topic_title
0.000318 - SELECT * FROM config WHERE (conf_modid = '0' AND conf_catid = '5') ORDER BY conf_order ASC
0.000337 - SELECT * FROM config WHERE (conf_modid = '0' AND conf_catid = '3') ORDER BY conf_order ASC
0.001603 - SELECT o.tag_id, o.tag_term FROM tag_link AS l LEFT JOIN tag_tag AS o ON o.tag_id = l.tag_id WHERE l.tag_itemid = 1955 AND l.tag_modid = 32 ORDER BY o.tag_count DESC
0.000287 - SELECT COUNT(*) FROM group_permission WHERE (gperm_modid = '1' AND (gperm_groupid = '3') AND gperm_name = 'system_admin' AND gperm_itemid = '14')
0.000313 - SELECT COUNT(*) FROM group_permission WHERE (gperm_modid = '32' AND (gperm_groupid = '3') AND gperm_name = 'news_submit')
0.000208 - SELECT COUNT(*) as cpt FROM topics WHERE menu=1
0.000838 - SELECT * FROM xoopscomments WHERE (com_modid = '32' AND com_itemid = '1955' AND com_pid = '0') ORDER BY com_id ASC
Total: 37
Blocks
User Menu: Not cached
Search: Not cached
Custom Block (HTML): Not cached
Custom Block (HTML): Not cached
Custom Block (HTML): Not cached
Custom Block (HTML): Not cached
Cumulus Tag Cloud: Not cached
Custom Block (HTML): Not cached
Custom Block (HTML): Not cached
Custom Block (HTML): Not cached
Total: 10
Extra
Included files: 118 files
Memory usage: 8996128 bytes
Timers
XOOPS took 0.190 seconds to load.
XOOPS Boot took 0.033 seconds to load.
Module init took 0.028 seconds to load.
XOOPS output init took 0.045 seconds to load.
Module display took 0.074 seconds to load.
Page rendering took 0.008 seconds to load.